Get a new one. I have to agree with the "dont throw the baby out with the bath water" statement. I recently purchased a Speedmaster (about 3 months ago) and have had no problems. I have 2200 miles on it so far and love the bike. I cant say Im an expert on bikes considering this is my first one, but Im pretty sure that Harley wouldnt offer you the same deal if you had a problem with theirs. This offer speaks volumes to the companies customer service...something Harley and others seem to be lacking when i was shopping for a bike. Also, being in sales myself, there is no better warranty than a company that is offering complete replacement or complete money back including interest. That screams confidence in their product! Chances are that this is an isolated issue and that you fall in love for a long time with a new one.
