FWIW, I've always rented from Orlando H/D.
I USE to get any bike, other than the "customs", for a total of $104.95 a day, after-the-fact, including the $10 a day insurance. (That's puttin' 3K on the card for damage responsibilities. [I figured IF I got involved with any damages, I wouldn't be around to worry about paying for it

])
Movin' ahead five years, When I had to rent the Sportster for two weeks, they (Orlando H/D) wanted over $100 a day (no specials at that time), plus insurance, $35 a day. With junior behind the bars for the Georgia Rally (and beyond), I "re-thought" the damage responsibilities, and went with the best coverage, which was 0 responsibility. Eagleriders was $69 a day (again, no specials at that time), AND their best coverage (same as Harley's) was $5 a day cheaper.
When we returned it, after 2,500 miles without a wash, they had no issues, AKA added costs.

(BOTH companies were really good about that!

)
But the bottom line is, Eagleriders was about $40 a day cheaper for the same item, same insurance, and same policies/rules. Multiply that by the twelve days we had it, and, well....
My next rental WILL again be with Eagleriders. I'm REALLY HAPPY with the treatment I received. (Though I've never heard of Streeteagle, I will check them out)