Well, ******!

Yeah, I figure they are in need of replacement due to age alone.

They feel soft to the touch, but there is minimal cracking.

What tires is everyone recommending? Primary focus is performance and ride comfort. Longevity is of lesser importance.

Is there somewhere that rates MC tires based on different criteria? (Like Tirerack's rating scale)

I have looked at the Tech Vault tire thread, but it is older and didn't say which tires were best suited for different types of riding.