Dear Billy Indiana,
Go with the clear Alley Cat, I have one on Lola. The tinted one will look like you have a black trash bag over it. And speaking of storage cases, do you plan to fly and carry your windshield with you ? TSA will wonder about you, much like they wonder about me when I fly. If you are worried about your windshield getting scratched up sitting in your garage, then get a black plastic trash bag and put over it prophylactically. I hope this sheds illumination upon your dilemma and you emerge from the Valley of Decision glowing with enlightenment. Best wishes, and stay green.
Sincerely, Captain Weedwhacker