After a couple of months with my Memphis Fats 17" screen, I find it is perfect for my needs. Just right on cold days, no buffeting like I experienced with the Roadster (although didn't realize it). Pops off in literally under a minute for warm weather use.
We had some unusually warm late Fall riding days and without the screen, I took some serious hits to the face/ear with large bugs. A few left some noticable welts so the screen went right back on. No more ouches.