Well, here's the update.
1. Swapped the bulb from the bad side to the good side and it works.
2. Swapped the wiring harness from the good side to the bad and visa versa and the bad side still doesn't work, while the good continued to work so I ruled out bad wiring.
3. Finally, I used a voltmeter and confirmed that I'm getting juice to the wiring just behind the light housing, but not in the housing itself
I sent bellacorse an email about getting a replacement light...we'll see how long that takes to get a reply.
